RR Logo RGB.png
×

How to Get One New Appointment Approved When Recruitment Budgets Are Tight

You've got a role that needs filling, a team that's already stretched and a budget that suggests now isn't the right time to bring anyone else into the business. It's a familiar situation for many employers, particularly when the pressure to control costs is competing with the need to keep things moving.

The difficulty is that the work doesn't stop simply because there's a pause on new appointments. Projects still need delivering, customers still expect a good service and the people already in the business can only take on so much before something starts to give.

There are plenty of businesses taking a cautious approach to recruitment at the moment.

The British Chambers of Commerce's Quarterly Recruitment Outlook, published in July 2026, found that 66% of UK businesses planned to keep staffing levels as they were, while 23% expected to increase them and 11% anticipated a reduction.

The Bank of England's Decision Maker Panel paints a similar picture, with businesses expecting employment growth of just 0.1% over the following year.

However, being careful about recruitment spending doesn't necessarily mean you shouldn't recruit. It means being able to explain why a particular appointment is needed, what it will contribute and what the business stands to lose by continuing without it.

And sometimes, one well-justified appointment can make considerably more sense than asking everyone else to keep doing a little bit more.
What a Pause on Recruitment Really Means
When a business puts restrictions on recruitment, it's often less about stopping all appointments and more about taking a closer look at which roles genuinely need to be filled.

Replacing someone who has left, bringing in a skill that's missing from the business or appointing someone who can help deliver an important project may still be possible, particularly when there's a clear reason behind the request.

The Bank of England's regional agents reported in September 2026 that businesses which were continuing to recruit were generally doing so to address skills shortages or support specific growth and investment projects.

Some organisations are also managing reductions in staffing levels through natural turnover, which means that when someone leaves, their role isn't necessarily replaced. Over time, this can leave teams with fewer people but very much the same amount of work.

There's also the changing employment legislation to consider. From 1 January 2027, the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal protection in England, Scotland and Wales will reduce from two years to six months, and the cap on compensatory awards will be removed. While this isn't a reason to rush into appointments, it's another consideration for employers making decisions about their workforce and future staffing requirements.

The important point is that a cautious recruitment budget doesn't automatically mean a business has to manage without the skills and experience it needs. It simply makes the reasoning behind each appointment more important.
The Real Cost of Leaving a Role Unfilled
When a vacancy isn't filled, the salary saving is usually quite easy to identify. It sits neatly in the budget, and everyone can see the difference it makes to the monthly figures.

What isn't quite so easy to measure is the cost of not having somebody doing the job.

Perhaps customer enquiries are taking longer to deal with, existing projects are being pushed back or opportunities are being turned away because there simply isn't enough capacity to take them on. You might also find that managers are spending more time covering operational work and less time doing the things they're actually employed to do.

In some businesses, the consequences are relatively straightforward to calculate. If an unfilled role means fewer orders can be processed, less work can be completed or a contract cannot be delivered on time, there's a financial impact that deserves to be considered alongside the salary saving.

In others, the cost is less obvious, particularly when the extra work is gradually absorbed by other people. It doesn't necessarily appear as an additional expense, but that doesn't mean it isn't affecting productivity, customer service or the ability to move the business forward.

Putting some realistic figures against the work that's being delayed or missed can make a considerable difference to the conversation. Instead of simply asking for permission to recruit, you're showing what the business is currently giving up by not making the appointment.
Don't Forget the People Already Doing the Work
There's another part of this that can easily be overlooked, and that's the effect an unfilled role has on everyone else.

The work doesn't disappear when somebody leaves or an appointment is put on hold. It tends to be shared between the people who are still there, often those who are already reliable, capable and carrying a fairly full workload of their own.

Initially, everyone might manage quite happily, particularly if they understand that the situation is temporary. The problem comes when temporary arrangements become the normal way of working, and the additional responsibilities are never properly addressed.

The CIPD's 2025 Health and Wellbeing at Work survey, which covered 1,101 UK organisations, found that heavy workloads were the most frequently reported cause of stress-related absence, accounting for 41% of organisations reporting this type of absence.

The same research recorded average employee absence of 9.4 days a year, the highest figure the CIPD had reported in more than 15 years. Meanwhile, the Health and Safety Executive estimated that 22.1 million working days were lost across Great Britain in 2024/25 because of work-related stress, depression or anxiety.

These figures don't mean that leaving one vacancy unfilled will automatically result in additional absence, but they do reinforce the importance of taking workload seriously. If the same people are continually expected to pick up extra responsibilities, there's a risk that the business eventually loses the very people it was relying on to keep things running.

Replacing one missing person could then become a much bigger and more expensive problem.
Making a Business Case That Gets Taken Seriously
If you're asking for permission to recruit when budgets are under pressure, it's worth thinking about the questions your finance director or leadership team is likely to ask.

Simply explaining that the team is busy or that somebody needs to be replaced might not be enough. You'll need to show why the appointment matters and what the consequences are if the business continues without it.
Start with what's not getting done
Be specific about the work that's being delayed, missed or passed between other employees. Is there a backlog developing, are customers waiting longer for a response or are managers spending time covering responsibilities that should sit elsewhere? 

The more clearly you can explain the situation, the easier it becomes for someone else to understand why a replacement or additional appointment is needed.
Explain the financial impact
Where possible, connect the role to something the business already values, whether that's generating income, retaining an important customer, meeting contractual commitments or delivering a particular project. It's much easier to justify an appointment when there's a clear link between the person being recruited and the results the business needs to achieve.
Be realistic about the salary
This is one area where getting the figures right from the beginning really matters. There's little point putting together a business case based on a salary that won't attract the experience you're looking for, only to discover a few months later that the budget needs revisiting.

The Bank of England's Decision Maker Panel found that businesses expected pay growth of 3.4% over the following year, while its regional agents put the average pay settlement for 2026 at around 3.6%.

These are general figures, of course, and they won't necessarily reflect the salary required for a particular position. What matters is understanding what someone with the right experience is likely to expect in the current UK market, rather than relying on a salary range that may have been appropriate a year or two ago.
Explain why waiting isn't necessarily the cheaper option
Finally, consider what another three months without the appointment might mean. Will a project be delayed, will the existing team continue to struggle with additional work or could the business lose an opportunity that won't come around again?

A realistic explanation of what happens if the decision is postponed can be just as important as explaining why the appointment is needed in the first place.
Could You Manage Without Making a Permanent Appointment?
It's also worth considering whether employing someone permanently is the only answer. Sometimes there's a more practical way to deal with the immediate problem, and being open to alternatives will make your case more credible.

Contractors and temporary employees can be useful when there's a specific project to complete, a short-term increase in workload or a requirement for specialist skills over a defined period. They're not always the best answer when the position depends on building long-term customer relationships, developing knowledge within the business or providing ongoing support to the rest of the team.

An internal move might work if there's someone ready to take on additional responsibility, but it's important to consider what happens to the work they're currently doing. Otherwise, you could simply be moving the problem from one department to another.

Training existing employees can also be a sensible investment, particularly when the skills needed are relatively straightforward to develop. However, it takes time, and it won't always address an immediate gap in experience or capacity.

The British Chambers of Commerce reported that only 20% of businesses increased their investment in training during the second quarter of 2026, while 20% reduced it.

There's also a risk in assuming that suitable candidates will be readily available whenever the business decides the time is right. The ONS's Business Insights and Conditions Survey in December 2025 found that half of businesses with 10 or more employees experiencing recruitment difficulties cited a lack of qualified applicants.

In other words, waiting until the business feels more comfortable about recruitment spending doesn't guarantee that finding the right person will become any easier.
Where Recruit Recruit Can Help
If you're trying to get an appointment approved, having a better understanding of the current employment market can make the discussion considerably easier.

At Recruit Recruit, we work with businesses across the UK to help them understand what it takes to attract the right people, including what similar positions are paying, what candidates are looking for and how realistic their expectations are.

The Bank of England's regional agents have continued to report shortages in specialist and technical positions, even though recruitment activity has eased more generally. The British Chambers of Commerce also found that 73% of businesses attempting to recruit reported difficulties.

That makes it particularly important to have a realistic picture of who's available and what it might take to attract them. There's little value in securing approval for a position if the salary, responsibilities or expectations make it difficult to find the person you actually need.

A little preparation before you approach the decision makers can save considerable time later, particularly if you can demonstrate that the appointment has been properly considered and that there's a realistic plan for filling it.
Sometimes One Good Appointment Makes All the Difference
Being careful about recruitment spending makes sense, but there's a difference between controlling costs and leaving a business without the people it needs to operate effectively.

If an unfilled position is affecting productivity, putting additional pressure on an already busy team or preventing the business from taking advantage of opportunities, it's worth looking beyond the salary saving and considering the bigger picture.

A convincing case doesn't need to be complicated. It needs to explain what's happening now, what the business stands to lose by doing nothing, what the appointment will contribute and what it will realistically cost.
If you've got a position you'd like to fill but aren't sure how to make the case for it, get in touch with me. I'm happy to talk through the role, share some insight into the current market and help you work out what a realistic appointment might look like.

Sometimes, getting the right person into one position is exactly what the business needs to make everything else a little easier.